Eddie’s Sweet Shop in Forest Hills – A Neighborhood Classic

Forest Hills, a cherished New York neighborhood, exudes a tranquil charm that feels like a serene oasis within the city. Its tree-lined streets, historic Tudor-style homes, and close-knit community create a unique blend of old and new. The area's rich history sets it apart from the bustling parts of Queens. Whether strolling through the enchanting Forest Hills Gardens or discovering the local shops and restaurants along Austin Street, you'll be captivated by the neighborhood's timeless allure.

What sets Forest Hills apart is its sense of tradition, where long-standing businesses thrive alongside the new. Among these iconic spots, one place holds a special spot in the hearts of locals: Eddie’s Sweet Shop, a living testament to the neighborhood's rich history and enduring charm.

A Community Favorite: Eddie’s Sweet Shop

Tucked away on Metropolitan Avenue, Eddie’s Sweet Shop has been a Forest Hills institution since 1925. It’s the kind of place that immediately transports you back in time with its marble counters, tin ceilings, and vintage soda fountain vibe. Whether you’re stopping by after a day of exploring the neighborhood or just craving a nostalgic treat, Eddie’s never disappoints.

The shop is known for its homemade ice cream, and it’s no surprise that it’s become a staple for generations of families in the area. There’s a sense of tradition here—parents bring their kids, who eventually bring their own, making Eddie’s a cherished part of the Forest Hills experience.

My Favorite at Eddie’s

While their sundaes and milkshakes are local legends, my absolute go-to is the ice cream soda. You get to choose your syrup and ice cream, all topped with their amazing homemade whipped cream. For the perfect cherry-filled dessert, I recommend the cherry vanilla ice cream with cherry syrup and, of course, a cherry on top of the whipped cream.

A Sweet Tradition in Forest Hills

Eddie’s Sweet Shop isn’t just about ice cream—it’s about the memories that come with it. It’s a place where the old-fashioned charm of Forest Hills is lovingly preserved and celebrated. So, if you ever find yourself in this historic neighborhood, make sure to stop by Eddie’s for a taste of tradition and a reminder of why this corner of Queens is so special. Trust me, it’s an essential stop on your NYC bucket list.

Getting to Eddie’s Sweet Shop

From Brooklyn:

• Subway: Take the G train to Court Square, then switch to the E or M to Forest Hills – 71st Ave and walk from there.
• Car: Use the BQE to Queens Boulevard, turning onto Continental Avenue.

From Manhattan:

• Subway: Take the E, F, M, or R to Forest Hills – 71st Ave, then walk to Eddie’s.
• Car: Follow Queens Boulevard into Forest Hills.

From the Bronx:

• Subway: Take the 4 or D to 59th Street, then the E or M to Forest Hills – 71st Ave.
• Car: Use the Major Deegan to the Triborough Bridge to Queens.

From Staten Island/New Jersey:

• Subway: Take the Staten Island Ferry to Manhattan, then the E or F to Forest Hills.
• Car: Cross into Brooklyn and take the Belt Parkway to Metropolitan Avenue.

From Westchester/Long Island:

• Subway: Take the LIRR to Forest Hills.
• Car: Use the LIE or Cross Bronx to Queens Boulevard.

No matter where you’re coming from, visiting Eddie’s Sweet Shop is worth the trip. Whether by car or public transit, getting there is easy—and once you arrive, you’ll be treated to a sweet slice of history.